Comparing Apples. Oranges Need Not Apply
We went to go check out the iPhones yesterday.
I walked into AT&T. "Can we help you?" they asked.
"I'm here about the iHype," I replied.
The guy gave us a demo, but he didn't have a real idea as to how to use it. Apparently they kept them secret until the very last minute. So the guy sort of appeared ham-handed on the thing. He wasn't sure if the calendar could issue reminders (it can) and he kept trying to tap the screen twice for every function. Good for Windows, bad for iPhones. He also took a couple of photos, but they looked terribly blurry. Hmmm...what, you need a tripod for this thing? I wasn't allowed to hold the iPhone. I was told it was a "security rule." What, like I'm going to dash out the door with it? I haven't been able to dash out the door of anyplace (including home) for about the last six years or so. I have two kids, mister. I don't dash anywhere.
Today we went to the Apple store. I got an email from a friend who stood in line to get an iPhone, and her words were, "It really is the second coming." (Bloggers are calling it the Jesus Phone.) So we thought it would be good to go to the source to check it out. The iPhone isn't perfect, IMO. Here are the most major flaws that I see:
- The browser (which rocks) doesn't support Java or Flash. This means I can't use it to pull up k12.com. It locks other users out of a lot of content on the web. (As if other phones CAN support Java and Flash. HA!! They don't.)
- The phone runs on the EDGE network. Legend says it's painfully slow and antiquated. I'm not sure I buy that, however. Doug's Blackberry (T-Mobile) also runs on the EDGE network, and he's had no trouble with it.
- The phone likes to try and predict what you're trying to type. It's almost impossible to REJECT those changes. Essentially, you can't use abbreviations. I want to type "SLSC HS Class," not "St Louis Science Center Home School Class," thank-you-very-much.
- You can set up repeating events, but not on a monthly basis that's not date-based. So I can't put in my Graphic Design meetings for the second Tuesday of each month, or my LLL Series meetings for the first Monday of each month. "Well, there are always software updates," says the rep. "There's a software update for that?" I ask. "Well, I'm sure there will be." Blink. ?!?!?!? WTF?
On the upside:
- OMG, it has a full browser! Wow!
- The keyboard isn't nearly as difficult as everyone makes it out to be.
- You can actively push email TO the iPhone. It doesn't even come close to a Blackberry in this respect, but it's not trying to. Still, you can tell it to go fetch your email from your personal account every X minutes, which is kinda cool.
- Um...it's an iPhone. Do you know how cool those things are?
While I was doing this, a guy stopped behind me and watched me draw for a minute, then started asking questions about architectural and landscape renderings on the Mac, and would you use Illustrator or AutoCad, etc. I was quite flattered, actually.
Leopard, the new OS for Mac, is coming out around October. They have a new finder which practically makes me cry with desire. Doug utterly doesn't it. "Ok, fine, it's cool, but what IS it about this thing that makes you so...?"
"Because it talks to me. I speak Eyes. It speaks Eyes. I don't have to translate. It's like finally getting a newspaper in your native language. Do you have any idea how many files I open just to see if they're the ones I'm trying to find? This...isn't disruptive. In one way it lets me think, and in another way it doesn't make me think. I don't have to stop and switch gears back and forth." What the heck is "speaking Eyes?" Watch this.
And finally, we took our iPod back to the Apple store and they exchanged it for a new one. I noticed this afternoon that the center button on the click wheel seemed to be sunken in more than it ought to be, and it wasn't quite as responsive. (And yes, those stupid things are made in China, too.) It has a one-year warranty, so we took it back and they quickly and painlessly handed us a new one.




